Forum Moderators: buckworks
1. I get a separate domain for the items I want to sell and link to it
2. I put a buy know next to the items I do want to sell. (which I think may frustrate and confuse customers because they cant buy everything).
3. Make a 2 links on my nav bar to say "online store" and "retail store" and have a separate sections.
Any thoughts?
You should be able to do this relatively cheaply and quickly. You can see this as "dipping your toe in the water" in terms of ecommerce, and if it works out for you, you'll have a clear idea of the cost/benefit involved in expanding your online operations.
I think with a single domain you can avoid having duplicate content, which if I am understanding you correctly could be a potential problem. This is because any content shown on the "online store" would also be available in the "retail store" part of the website.
Good luck by the way .. unless you plan on competing with me ;-) .
If you make a section "we can get this" ... customers aren't going to see the headline "CAN GET". They're going to walk in and expect it to be there (and for CHEAPER than what you offer on the web, regardless of what currency your website handles in default!)
With a single domain you will have an easier time with marketing, and you won't run the risk of confusing potential customers. I'd be willing to bet that you are likely missing out on BIG BUSINESS by not selling your products directly online via credit cad, paypal, etc.
Learn as much as you can and take things slow. Who knows, by the next time the holiday season come around, you could be rolling in the dough.