Forum Moderators: phranque

Message Too Old, No Replies

Search engine comparatives - web statistics

Difference between your stats and those of the stats marketeers

         

pete

3:10 pm on Jan 22, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Clients are always very interested in regard to which search engines provide the lions share of the traffic.

Fair enough! Any fool can position someones site on notonehit.com (just ask me ;) ). The trick is to position a clients site on the most popular search engines for the correct key terms!

It should be simple then. Motivate to the client which engines are the most popular and from that, present a performance based quote!

But, I find that there is a large disparity between the search engines that I regard as key in comparison to the ones that the stats houses (Mediametrix, Top9, Statmarket e.t.c) list as important.

Inevitably, the client wants objective stats to draw conclusions from which means that they side with the stats houses and not you which hurts them in the long run!

For example, according to Top9, Google comes in at number 10 for visitors!

Visitors (x000)
1 yahoo.com 65,415
2 msn.com 46,739
3 lycos.com 22,863
4 netscape.com 18,816
5 nbci.com 17,982
6 excite.com 17,452
7 about.com 16,291
8 iwon.com 15,350
9 altavista.com 14,128
10 google.com 13,747
11 go.com 12,097
12 goto.com 11,247
13 looksmart.com 11,115
14 go2net.com 6,313
15 directhit.com 5,728

Who here reckons that Google is number 10 on the list?

Black Knight

3:18 pm on Jan 22, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



That's mainly because the stats are based on traffic at those domains, rather than traffic purely from the search engines at those domains.

So, Yahoo, with its portal features, web-based email etc, etc gets a lot of traffic that is not at all related to search. Even if you narrowed the stats to just show referrals from the portals, those stats would include anyone clicking a link in an email (web based).

There's a longer discussion of the metrics systems, their limitations and failings, over at SearchEngineWatch.com if you are interested.

ritualcoffee

3:50 pm on Jan 22, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



you will also see different engine being important for different types of markets you're trying to reach. For example, Google seems to be #1 for the tech community, whereas MSN, AOL, Altavista for mass consumers.

pete

4:06 pm on Jan 22, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Black_knight, I considered this and agree!

Providing that explanation will alleviate some clients fears from thinking that you are pulling a fast one on them but the insecure ones start getting jittery!

Ill have a look at the search engine watch article and probably use it as some ammo. thanks!

Ritual,

We optimise clients sites in various industries and find Google to be top of the pops in all of them! Interested to see that Altavista is still on your list!

ritualcoffee

7:03 pm on Jan 22, 2002 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



interestingly, AV is our fourth largest referrer worldwide.
I don't really care as long as those referrers keep coming! :)