Forum Moderators: phranque
Stephen
I don't think you should merge the two. The benefits of having two domains are that you can target each towards slightly different phrases and also if the rankings drop for one you still have the other. Furthermore since you have two domains you can get two Yahoo! lisings, two DMOZ listings (maybe), etc.
For example, you want to target the handcrafted domain toward handcrafted key phrases. Then you want to target the other domains toward the main products for that domain...