Forum Moderators: martinibuster

Message Too Old, No Replies

Google AdSense Account Disabled.

i don't know.

         

wennuan

7:19 am on Sep 15, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



my have $15000+ in my account.

and $600 per day.

i can makes more than $15K a month?

my have 8 site and co-operate some of the webmaster in the net.

all site have total 300k hits / day.

[edited by: wennuan at 7:25 am (utc) on Sep. 15, 2004]

Hugene

11:33 pm on Sep 22, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Is there programs/scripts that click on the adsense on somebody else's site? I would be surprised if there is, as everyone would use it on their competitors. Or maybe theres is a way of copying the http headers that adsense clicks generate, and then repeat them a huge ammount of times.

The other way a competitor can harm is through manual clicking, but with 300k page views, a human can not do enough impact I think.

Maybe adsense might believe that clicks generated from ur site are not valuable to their customers and they want to termenitate the account (even though that is kind of ilegal, but with the whole proprietary secret monitoring systems , there is no way of knowing)

Kinitz

11:33 pm on Sep 22, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Due to the proprietary nature of our monitoring system, we cannot disclose any specific details of these clicks.

This is the most evil sentence I have seen in my life and I really have experienced a lot of evil.

It is simply impossible that this sentence is compatible with Google's "Do no evil" principle, which Google is showing off.

I am in deep shock. Scenes from the world war 2 come to my mind where people were killed without giving reasons. I am really in deep shock :-(

Critter

11:50 pm on Sep 22, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Evil or not, the TOS for Adsense states that they reserve the right to terminate any publisher at any time at their sole discretion.

There's nobody standing over you with a gun to your head making you agree to the TOS; if you don't like the wording then don't agree to it.

Simple.

I would imagine that the complainant did some dirty tricks and thought he'd never get caught. But he got caught. :)

Google is not going to can someone's account for no good reason: it's not in their best interest to do so. Contrariwise it's not wise for them to keep a fraudster on the system and give them a "second chance" to game their system and possibly succeed.

Kinitz

12:04 am on Sep 23, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



There's nobody standing over you with a gun to your head making you agree to the TOS; if you don't like the wording then don't agree to it.

Google Adsense gives more money to webmasters than other programs. It is simply impossible to ignore it because if your competition is using Adsense then they have more resources than you - if you don't use it - to better compete against you!

In other words: for most webmasters using Adsense is a must. That's the harsh reality.

And regarding "he probably was guilty" I can tell you that I have heard of several cases where people were in holidays or in business trips and never ever would click themselves - it was clearly a case of competition working on destroying their sites, but Google fall for it and terminated them.

I know even more but I don't want to violate TOS of this forum. I just hope that Google will be reasonable and will also not terminate me. If Google would do it I don't know what I would do. Go mad? Probably.

Critter

12:12 am on Sep 23, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Well the overriding argument I'm making is this: If Google's making probably over 10K/mth from this fellow it's not in their best interest to ban him unless they've *absolutely proved to themselves* that he was up to no good. And that would entail connecting the fraudulent clicks to the publisher.

If it's not the publisher doing it then, by any stretch of the imagination, it's going to be *another* publisher trying to get the first party banned; in which case the rogue publisher (second party) is putting their own Adsense standing in jeopardy.

Like the old saying goes: The jails are just full of innocent victims :)

Kinitz

12:38 am on Sep 23, 2004 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



in which case the rogue publisher (second party) is putting their own Adsense standing in jeopardy

Your logic is cunning, but what if this second rogue publisher has been already terminated by Google and he has nothing to lose? You know what does it mean? It means that Google is terminating innocent people because totally independent other rogue webmasters want them to be terminated! And long-reaching consequence of this is one: sooner or later some genius will write a program (something like Agent Smith or Neo) that will totally destroy the Google Matrix. Either Google must change quickly or Neo or Agent Smith are coming...

This 36 message thread spans 2 pages: 36