Forum Moderators: Robert Charlton & goodroi
1 year anniversary of penguin, no recovery
I mentioned that observation too, right after the patent hit the light of day.
I would think if they really weren't using it at all he wanted to "put the "misconceptions they were to rest" he would just flat out "we're not using that right now at all" just like he has with the keyword meta tag, but he doesn't say it's not being used anywhere in the video.
Obviously without the half dozen threads at Google Group and the 200 posts dedicated to this specific topic I cannot possibly make you see the connection.
[edited by: TheOptimizationIdiot at 8:45 pm (utc) on May 3, 2013]
And in this one you're saying a site that didn't do any link development probably lost their inorganic (developed) links and that's why they don't rank now. Uh, not sure I follow that one either.
Can you explain how you think a site that didn't build links lost it's rankings due to inorganic (developed) links being discounted, because I'm not sure I follow your reasoning.
Maybe I don't understand what you're calling inorganic links, because the post about the site clearly states they didn't build any links to it, so what are you referring to as inorganic links in a situation where links were not being built prior to or after Penguin?
That's still the case, I think, and I'm wiling to back off on using this particular patent in my day-to-day thinking - even if some "anecdotal evidence" seems to pop up from time to time.
No... if you have no links or few links the day you launched your website you don't rank very well. It isn't because you are devalued it's because you haven't built that value yet.
You lost me from discussing with this one.
Totally invalid assumption. I have a site that's been pinned to #1 for what it was designed to rank for since about a week after it launched with 1 non-scraper link. It's going on 6 years of sitting there now.
As a software engineer I'll tell you why I don't think it's easy to recover from Penguin or some of the other stuff they're now doing. I think they flag your domain when they run they're Penguin software and once you're flagged, that's it, you can't squirm and try to get out of it without manual assistance.
The easiest way to "recover" IMO is to move to a new domain
there hasn't been a Penguin update since October 2012
We're not going to change our brand to chase google.
...so just switching the ecommerce to shop.example.com should be enough to bypass the flagged domain...
As a software engineer I'll tell you why I don't think it's easy to recover from Penguin or some of the other stuff they're now doing. I think they flag your domain when they run they're Penguin software and once you're flagged, that's it, you can't squirm and try to get out of it without manual assistance.
As my sport went into hibernation for the summer, the impressions dropped even lower, down to around 100,000 to 150,000 per day. Traffic was down by almost 50% from the prior year, though part of this was because the top league of the sport that my site focuses on was on the verge of cancelling their season.
Then, on October 13, bam! The impressions skyrocketed to 450,000. It can be argued that October is the time of the year when my traffic normally picks up, but the increase was too sharp for this to be that kind of increase. It was clearly a recovery.
My primary theory on why I recovered is that my site had a non-typical backlink profile which falsely tripped Penguin, and that on October 13 Google rolled out a fix that corrected their error. My secondary theory (which I hope is not true) is that there is a traffic threshold level for Google's penalties, and that from April to October, due to the seasonality of my sport, my traffic dropped below the threshold and lost its ability to overcome a penaltywhich might still be lurking out there.
[edited by: Whitey at 2:52 am (utc) on May 4, 2013]
I'm not sure that anyone this side of google knows when or how often penguin has been run.
Well,im in the same boat you guys are in and I changed my domain name last year and still can not recover
I'm finding these days that less is more when it comes to SEO
[edited by: TheOptimizationIdiot at 5:37 am (utc) on May 4, 2013]
But @fathom - you say that Ralph_Slate was not Penguined. I'm 20/80 - more on the side of Penguin because of the dates.
If you lost 80% of your traffic you probably lost 80% of your backlinks and you could say you moved 80% back in time when you didn't have as many links, ranks, and all that comes with it as you did when you got nailed.
People want things like keyword density analysis
Clients didn't like to hear what I had to say which was look at your analytics reports because running keyword reports is a waste of time, just see which keywords are generating traffic and simply focus on those and maybe not so much on those that don't.
Sure, you might like to be on the big keywords, but if you can find 100 other keywords that rank easily then go for the low hanging fruit and fig in hard before someone else notices.
If you didn't like me giving away the farm before, you're gonna hate this dose of reality...
[edited by: TheOptimizationIdiot at 7:42 am (utc) on May 4, 2013]
[edited by: mcneely at 7:30 am (utc) on May 4, 2013]
Just changing domain names without attempting to fix anything that potentially caused the problem would be like changing socks without taking antibiotics and wondering why the new socks didn't cure the big infected foot wound.Absolutely!
A new domain of subdomain would only get you away from the flag on your domain, you would still need to make some changes and fix whatever might have caused the problem.
Any keyword stuffing, title stuffing, link madness, etc. would need to be addressed.
Basically, a nice plain vanilla site made for humans and not geared for any type of SEO whatsoever would be where I would start and see what happens, then slowly make SEO changes and not get aggressive about those changes.
I'm finding these days that less is more when it comes to SEO because too much invalidates the whole thing and you're sitting there with a ton of work nobody can find.
Actually, I did not lose any backlinks after Penguin. Since then, I've lost a few and gained a few, as one does when one is letting the links happen naturally."Lose" implied the loss of link juice asssociated with the links that are obviously still there.
I've launched 3 since the Penguin, 3 new domains, all with similar content, style and builds that the old ones had .. New ip's and servers .. Two of them are actually doing better now than the other two did before Penguin -- Two of them have actually gotten a bit of PR too. (I've dumbed down, or otherwise simplified the content on the new sites however with an eye toward the casual reader/visitor)