Forum Moderators: Robert Charlton & goodroi

Message Too Old, No Replies

Google Adsense still being counted in site speed

         

drall

3:50 pm on Jul 18, 2010 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



We have ran over 10 tests using data from GWT site speed reporting and I am 99.9999% positive GWT site speed reporting is still taking page load of Google Adsense ads into the load factoring.

Here is what we tested.

1. We used a site with a pretty large sample size of 40,000 unique visitors per day. Text only adsense ads for the first phase of testing.

2. We tested the site for 7 days without adsense enabled to get a baseline speed. (note) when adsense was initially removed page speed increased by 40% according to GWT.

3. So now we have our baseline speed. We then enabled adsense serving again to the website. Page speed decreased on the exact day adsense was enabled by an average of 40%.

4. We then tested this 3 weeks running back and forth in 7 day tests with adsense on then off...

5. Each time we disabled adsense site speed would increase on average by 40%. Each time we enabled adsense site speed would decrease by 40%.

6. We then left adsense enabled for 10 days. We then enabled image ads within adsense and site speed decreased by an additional 25% over the original decrease of 40%.

7. We then removed adsense and GWT reported a 65% increase in site speed after removal.

Our conclusion, Google is still taking adsense code into account for it's GWT site speed factoring. They originally had it listed as a factor but after I pointed this out on this WW they took action to remove it.

Our data confirms that this has NOT been removed from the page load speed factoring at all. If it has been then Google needs to take another look at this because something is clearly not working.

tedster

6:23 am on Jul 19, 2010 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



What can I say, except that I think you're right. However, site speed is still only a small, small part of the total ranking picture. Even during your on/off/on testing, I'll bet it didn't affect ranking and traffic, right?

drall

2:47 pm on Jul 19, 2010 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Your right tedster, no traffic changes. Im just bringing this up because I am seeing tons of posts popping up with people overhauling sites to improve speed because GWT says they are slow and then loosing rankings as a result.

If you run adsense you should take this into account as to what GWT is telling you so you dont do a needless overhaul to increase site speed and then get whacked for traffic.

For all you know GWT is reporting site speed 50% wrong due to adsense and your site may be much faster then what Google is telling you.

If Google is going to be the world judge for sitespeed they shouldnt count you using Google products against you.

tedster

3:59 pm on Jul 19, 2010 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



When my clients get all hyped up about improving site speed because it's now a ranking factor, I usually tell them to chill out.

Unless some speed issue is powerfully affecting user experience, I do not recommend taking on the ranking and traffic risks that come with big site changes. Be sane, fix one thing at a time and do it for your visitors, not because you expect to see a pop in rankings.

levo

7:14 pm on Jul 19, 2010 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



Did Google announce that they won't take it into account? Adsense ads are a part of your visitors experience...

BTW, there is a slightly faster option for displaying adsense ads, especially if you're using DFP.

[google.com...]