Welcome to WebmasterWorld Guest from 22.214.171.124
So I plan to do 301 redirects from old pages to their equivalent new ones.
For old pages that do not have a directly equivalent new one, what should I do with them (especially those with deep links/PR)?
Should I just 404 them or is it acceptable to 301 redirect them to the home page (in a general way, they would still be on topic)?
Is there a maximum percentage of old pages that can be 301 redirected to the home page before it would have a negative effect?
If it's a browser 301 for the customer's convenience
Or you could just serve the browser a true 404 http header with a custom page to help the use navigate the site. I have served the browser a carbon-copy of the home page on some sites, but as a different url. That's probably a better bet than playing with user-agent delivery whcih might be interpereted as deceptive cloaking in some situations.
I suppose google could get paranoid about different returns but I don't see why it should. The web site is there for the punter's benefit, not google's.
There are a lot of reasons for legitimately "cloaking" certain content to stop google etc seeing it. The important thing is not to give them "spam" content that the punter doesn't see. Google should view what they are given and make decisions on that.
My personal view is that google are calling far too many scares and people are playing their game - we have to or lose trade. It's time they settled down a bit. :)