Forum Moderators: Robert Charlton & goodroi
Despite all my best efforts, we are not ranking well in Google.com search listings. Sites that have little content and link to us are ranking before our site. Strangely, the .com site shows well in Google Canada's search results. In fact, if you go to Google Canada and select the "pages from Canada" radio button, you find our .com site in the listings. So it appears that Google thinks our .com site is for Canadians.
My 2 questions:
1. Does the fact that Google thinks our site is more relevant to Canadians than Americans hurt our rankings in our Google.com results?
2. What other techniques should I go after to help Google realize the .com site is for Americans?
Still, I would suggest you bring this to their attention - you can use the Reconsideration Request form in WMT, or Google Groups. You could also do the "pages from canada" search and then use the link at the bottom of the results that says "Dissatisfied? Help us improve"
It's the fact that your site shows under "pages from Canada" that is the clearest evidence that they've got it wrong, in my opinion.
The other thing to consider is that google.com rankings are exponentially more difficult than the .ca rankings. Being #1 in a google.ca search may get you #300 rankings in google.com. (I just searched my domain in a local google vs. google.com. I'm #1 in the local google, #25 in google.com. #1 and #18 on another term. And I have a fair number of american backlinks.).
I suspect the solution is actually what tedster suggested, just throwing out those other two scenarios as things I've seen with geo googles.
http://www.webmasterworld.com/google/3687429.htm On results from google.co.uk [ filtered with "sites in UK" ] we are showing both our .COM and .co.uk site in positions 45 and 46 for the same term.
Neither site is hosted in the UK or has any Whois information for the UK. The only relationship with the UK is the TLD of the 2nd one.They also have different content.
Is there a Google UK glitch on at the moment ?
Possibly this is more widespread. We now have .com ; .co.uk and .ca and 2 reports