Forum Moderators: Robert Charlton & goodroi
The meta robots noindex tag allows the page to be spidered, but says to not allow the content to appear in the SERPs at all. Nothing about that page will appear in the SERPs.
Use whichever one is appropriate. If you use both, then Google will not ever get to the page to see the meta tag.
In fact, I can take any of these so-called "restricted" URLs and paste directly into google's OWN robots.txt analysis box under the Diagnostics tab, and they all come back as allowed.
One thing that set the alarm bells off for me recently was a URL that at first glance should have been indexed but was denied. Upon further investigation it was a URL that went to page that I had removed from the public. The redirect was going to the login page which of course is denied in robots.txt