Forum Moderators: martinibuster

Message Too Old, No Replies

high ctr less money per click?

         

Seleno

10:25 am on Apr 15, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Hello Every one
my high ctr yesterday is: 48.58%
but today is: 46.57%
so when my ctr is 46 i earned more per money per click
but for 48 i earned less
and the 46 ctr have more ecpm.....
so what is the better?
what do you think?

John Carpenter

12:18 pm on Apr 15, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Always compare ad unit eCPM's. It would be a mistake to compare only EPC or CTR. (Low-EPC ads often earn you more than high-EPC ads because of higher CTR.)

eCPM is a synthesis of all four figures -- EPC, CTR, earnings, and number of impressions -- which are all taken into an account in eCPM.

david_uk

1:03 pm on Apr 15, 2006 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



eCPM is a synthesis of all four figures -- EPC, CTR, earnings, and number of impressions -- which are all taken into an account in eCPM.

Eh? It's (earnings/impressions)*1000 isn't it? Clicks and ctr don't come into the equation - just earnings and impressions.

Seleno - I never use day to day figures in any meaningful data analysis. I generally use monthly data. I don't think anything can be drawn from comparing two days.

I have to say that the ctr is - erm, rather high.

Juan_G

1:33 pm on Apr 15, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



All are related. For example:

eCPM = (Earnings / Impr) * 1000
eCPM = CTR * EPC * 10

CTR = (Clicks / Impr) * 100
CTR = (eCPM / EPC) / 10

EPC = Earnings / Clicks
EPC = (eCPM / CTR) / 10

Earnings = EPC * Clicks
Earnings = eCPM * Impr / 1000

And so on.

About the first question, it's normal to see the contrary, for example high EPC (CPC) with high CTR -and high eCPM-, but there is a variety of different cases, with many other factors -known and unknown- involved (advertiser bids, smart pricing, etc.).

John Carpenter

4:09 pm on Apr 15, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Eh? It's (earnings/impressions)*1000 isn't it? Clicks and ctr don't come into the equation - just earnings and impressions.

You are obviously wrong. Both CTR and EPC affect earnings, so they affect eCPM too.

Why is eCPM so special? Because, as I already wrote, eCPM is affected by all the AdSense parameters. If EPC changes, eCPM changes too. If CTR changes, eCPM changes too. If number of impressions changes, eCPM takes it into an account.

CTR alone is useless. You can earn more on a day with 0.1% CTR than on a day with 90% CTR (due to different EPC).

EPC alone is useless. In total you can earn more on ads with EPC of $0.1 than on ads with EPC of $10 (due to different CTR).

Comparning earnings between two days may be misleading, because number of impressions may be different between the two days.

The bottom line, only eCPM can be reasonably compared between two days.

david_uk

4:19 pm on Apr 15, 2006 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



I know what eCPM is. I only wished to point out the mathematical formula used to calculate it so that the OP knew how it was arrived at. It sometimes helps to know how the figures we bandy around are calculated, and the post rather implied that clicks and ctr were used in the calculation.

I'd also like to make the point that eCPM is a standard way of comparing different revenue streams. For example, having several different pages with several different ad providors and widely varying site traffic/clicks. By using the eCPM figure you can easily compare all of these to see which ones work effectively.

The other point to make is that like epc, eCPM is useless in itself. My top channel for eCPM today is showing $273.98 - but it's only had two clicks. I use ALL metrics in tandem to get the full picture.

Juan_G

5:27 pm on Apr 15, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Especially useful equations are:

Earnings = eCPM * Impr / 1000
Earnings = CTR * EPC * Impr / 100
eCPM = CTR * EPC * 10

That is to say, for higher earnings, we need higher eCPM and/or more impressions. For higher eCPM, we need higher CTR and/or EPC.

It's "and/or" because for example we can get higher earnings from a good eCPM, even with fewer ad impressions, among many other different possibilities and combinations.

In general, for CTR we need that the users read the ads (reducing ad blindness with AdSense optimization, good placement, etc.) and also that they like the ads and click them (with targeted ads, that is topic-focused pages rather than general ones). For EPC (CPC) we need conversions and therefore a good smart pricing effect. And, finally, more impressions mean more traffic, of course.

It seems useful to remove ads from pages with very low eCPM, if it cannot be improved even after trying optimization. (You can try again ads on some of those pages from time to time, to verify any possible performance improvement). There is a controversy about a possible beneficial smart pricing effect from removing non-performing ads, but in any case -even without that possible effect- your readers will be grateful to see only the ads that they like and therefore click on, with frequent conversions from truly interested users. And happy users are the key to more and good traffic. ;)

david_uk

7:47 pm on Apr 15, 2006 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Especially useful equations are:
Earnings = eCPM * Impr / 1000
Earnings = CTR * EPC * Impr / 100
eCPM = CTR * EPC * 10

To be honest, although these formulae do indeed come up with the correct numbers, the issue is being confused.

Earnings = epc * number of clicks.

That's how Google calculate the amount that ends up in your bank account each month. Therefore both epc and number of clicks have great importance.

eCPM can have little relation to bottom line cash figure. For example, two days this month with virtually identical eCPM, bottom line cash figure on one of the days is 25% higher. Coversely, two days this month with similar bottom line cash figure, and vastly different eCPM.

Although I look at eCPM all the time, the way I use it mostly is in deciding what ad blocks stay, and what ones I delete.

The example I quoted earlier in the thread for 2 clicks and $200+ eCPM. I know that channel isn't visited a lot, but when it is, clicks usually pay well. Therefore, despite the very low earnings it will stay because it has a high eCPM and therefore is not likely to get the rest of the site smartpriced down the toilet. Contrast that with another page where the earnings are OK, but the number of page views and low number of clicks mean it's got a very poor eCPM. Therefore there is every chance that the poor performance on that page is going to get me smartpriced so it gets deleted.

People here can get hide-bound into relying solely on one metric. I believe you have to use ALL of the available statistics and ways of measuring site performance to tune your site for the optimum bottom line cash figure. Therefore, whilst eCPM is an important metric, epc and clicks have equal significance. And that's the point people here forget.

danimal

8:19 pm on Apr 15, 2006 (gmt 0)



all of the base-level stats like ctr give you valuable information... ecpm is the most worthless, because it's affected by too many variables to be of any real value.

epc matters the most to me, because that's what the advertisers are actually paying per click.

seleno, as was pointed out earlier, comparing day-to-day is not accurate... if anything, the numbers you posted are so close that you should be happy about it.

John Carpenter

8:59 pm on Apr 15, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



eCPM can have little relation to bottom line cash figure. For example, two days this month with virtually identical eCPM, bottom line cash figure on one of the days is 25% higher.

The example you gave basically says that your AdSense "success level" did not change. The only thing that changed was your traffic. Only eCPM can be used to make such a useful conclusion (earnings can't).

John Carpenter

9:05 pm on Apr 15, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



epc matters the most to me, because that's what the advertisers are actually paying per click.

ctr give you valuable information

If you earned $40 per click and I earned just $1 per click, I could still earn much more than you even if we had the same traffic. CTR is similarly useless for comparisons.

ecpm is the most worthless

Now take my previous example and imagine that our traffic is different. Then, only eCPM can be used to compare our AdSense success (efficiency).

It is all quite easy to understand, I believe.

david_uk

9:08 pm on Apr 15, 2006 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



In the example I gave, traffic played little part - epc did.

I'm not trying to pick a fight here. I am trying to make the point that when trying to view the bigger picture, all of these metrics have their purpose, and they are all fairly meaningless in isolation. eCPM has it uses, as do epc and ctr. Bottom line cash figure is what matters most. That's the figure that will pay for the family holiday in Corfu my wife is trying to book. No other metric will pay for this other than bottom line cash.

Seleno

12:07 am on Apr 16, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



well
thanx every one
so...more ctr=less money
for example if ctr is 8 and ecpm 10,will earn less than 2% ctr and 10ecpm....this is right.
frankly i register in google Adwords,
and i think i can earn better
adwords take much money
but if they take 0.04/click,i'll earn about 0.10/click some times.
so will earn about 150$ some times,
100$ for adwords and 50 for me(example)
and some times so less
some times high
but is it good way to get the trafic from adwords?
pay for them and take from adsense

Juan_G

12:20 am on Apr 16, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



well
thanx every one
so...more ctr=less money

No. :)

Sometimes, but usually not.

John Carpenter

10:13 am on Apr 16, 2006 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



all of these metrics have their purpose

The point is the OP tried to compare his AdSense success between two days. Only eCPM can be used for that. Earnings cannot be used because number of impressions is not taken into an account. CTR alone or EPC alone cannot be used either because they do not take Earnings into an account. eCPM takes all figures into an account. Simple.

(If you really need to have the last word, go ahead. I am not going to try to explain it over and over again.)

21_blue

12:08 pm on Apr 16, 2006 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Seleno wrote:
so...ctr is 8 and ecpm 10, will earn less than 2% ctr and 10ecpm

No, both earn exactly the same. If eCPM is $10 then, whatever the CTR, you are earning $10 for every thousand impressions.

If you are thinking about using Adwords for arbitrage, I suggest you get to grips with all the terms used & how Adsense works first, otherwise you might find yourself losing a lot of money.

danimal

5:23 pm on Apr 16, 2006 (gmt 0)



>>>The point is the OP tried to compare his AdSense success between two days. Only eCPM can be used for that.<<<

but you just told us that comparing just two days worth of earnings is misleading, which is indeed correct... so there is no way that you can justify using ecpm for a situation that isn't valid in the first place.

the reason that base stats are so valuable is because they tell you exactly what needs to be improved... got low ctr? try improving your page design, or even the source of your traffic... good ctr but low overall earnings? look at the epc history, the volume of traffic, add ypn to the pages with the lowest earnings, etc.

>>>My top channel for eCPM today is showing $273.98 - but it's only had two clicks.<<<

exactly my point, thank you... it boggles the mind to think that people make decisions about their websites based on an uncontrolled data source like ecpm.

seleno, juan_g also made some really good points about developing your site, based on stats.