Welcome to WebmasterWorld Guest from 54.196.233.239

Message Too Old, No Replies

Domain name selection optimized for Google

To Dash or Not to Dash?

     

tommyleebyron

11:12 am on Feb 3, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Hi Guys,

In terms of Google optimization what is best?

www.ironwidegets.com

or

www. iron-widgets.com?

thanks for the help!

joeking

2:07 pm on Feb 3, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



In my experience it makes no difference whatsoever.

Lord Majestic

2:45 pm on Feb 3, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



In my experience it makes no difference whatsoever.

Are you suggesting either of the following:

1) Google can split "bluewidget" into separate words "blue and widget" so that if someone searches for "blue widget" they will have a match (ranking is secondary issue)?

2) Ranking of domain matches is so low these days that it does not matter if there is a match in the first place?

joeking

3:07 pm on Feb 3, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Both 1 and 2 are true in my experience.

httpwebwitch

3:24 pm on Feb 3, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Administrator httpwebwitch is a WebmasterWorld Top Contributor of All Time 10+ Year Member



OK, then how do you split the word "potshard.com" Is it pots-hard or pot-shard? Google might be able to figure it out using site content in context, but then why would they bother?

In practice I prefer to hyphenatize things like file names and linked images. Does it make a difference? I have no proof, only suspicions and advice from other WMs.

my-image-name.gif
your-iframe-source.htm

With domain names I prefer no hyphens, because then I have to explain how it's spelled. How often have you said "the-dash-big-dash-happy-dash-web-dash-site-dot-com"?

joeking

3:34 pm on Feb 3, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



To ask how Google splits the words is irrelevant. The fact is that if you search for blue widget, both bluewidget.com and blue-widget.com will be seen as Google as relevant (how relevant depends on many other factors too).

It's easy to prove. Search Google for big money term and I find following:

1. widgets.com
2. word-widgets.com
3. wordwidget.com
4. word.com
5. wordword.com
6. madeupword.com
7. wordword.com
8. widgetsword.com
9. wordwidgets.com
10. wordword.com

This from 37,900,000 results for popular search word (it's the plural of where you might stay on vacation or while away on business if you're interested).

Lord Majestic

3:46 pm on Feb 3, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



both bluewidget.com and blue-widget.com will be seen as Google as relevant (how relevant depends on many other factors too).

Yes but those bluewidget.com's can appear not because there was a match in domain name (I got an impression that Google goes for exact match), but some naturally occuring "blue widget" keywords for both domains.

The question is therefore: if Google can't match those words in domains name, would that lose some brownie points that could have improved rankings?

siteseo

4:05 pm on Feb 3, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



In the past dashes "helped" Google find the individual words in your domain name. It *can* still help, but if you are at ALL interested in branding I would veer away from dashes. I can tell you from experiece that domains with three or more dashes in them can easily get tossed into the supplemental index. A spokeswoman from G stated publicly that anything with more than 2 dashes is considered "spammy." Now that doesn't mean you can't make it fly - especially if you get lots of great IBL's - but I would probably recommend either zero dashes or only one.

Same with file names. Underscores help readers see the words in the file name, but a crawler merely concatenates the separated words.

That said, I tend to use a dash in my domain names, as I'm primarily interested in SEO, not branding.

As long as you're focusing more on gaining quality links and developing quality content, you can really go either way.

Lord Majestic

4:23 pm on Feb 3, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



but if you are at ALL interested in branding

What about one dash, ie: mybrand-someword.com?

caveman

4:54 pm on Feb 3, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member caveman is a WebmasterWorld Top Contributor of All Time 10+ Year Member



Guys, G can identify kw's in the domain (just look at the SERP's and the URI's), but this sort of display is different from what goes into the algo calc and to my knowledge they do not factor the presense of a kw in domain into their rankings.

Think about it. There are way too many high quality entities - commercial and non-commercial - that do not include their most important kw's in their name (and domain name). Counting the presence of a kw in a domain would be essentially penalizing all those who don't have kw-in-domain, which would artificially skew the SERP's to sites that use kw's in domain (as an SEO tactic) ... and that's exactly what they don't want.

Matt Probert

5:28 pm on Feb 3, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



It DOES make a difference. We run one site, with two domain names.

One has a hyphen between the two words that comprise our site name, the other all one word - these being our product, so to speak.

The hyphenated domain always comes out of Google before the other when searching for the product by name.

For example (I have changed the names to examples for illustation only)

oak-tree.com and oaktree.com

Matt

caveman

6:08 pm on Feb 3, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member caveman is a WebmasterWorld Top Contributor of All Time 10+ Year Member



Nah. :-)

steveb

7:14 pm on Feb 3, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member steveb is a WebmasterWorld Top Contributor of All Time 10+ Year Member



It makes a big difference with Google, and an enormous difference with Yahoo and MSN.

Use oak-tree.com, point oaktree.com at it.

siteseo

7:46 pm on Feb 3, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Yah, you'll definitely want to 301 one of those domains to the other, Matt.

Caveman, I agree that site's don't NEED the kw in their domain to dominate the serps (just look at Amazon), but noone can state with 100% certainty that it won't help in some instances, all things being equal. It may only count for 1/10 of 1%, but that may be the difference between being #10 and being #11.

It's certainly not a magic bullet. And if that's the only thing you're doing to SEO your site...it ain't gonna help a bit.

BigDave

8:01 pm on Feb 3, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member bigdave is a WebmasterWorld Top Contributor of All Time 10+ Year Member



My guess (and it is only a guess) is that the domain name itself makes a very minor difference, it is the anchor text that ends up helping you.

If all your links are from link trades where you get to choose your anchor text, then I suspect that it will make little difference if your domain is bluewidgets.com, blue-wigets.com, or mamas-army-boots.com.

On the other hand, if many of your links use the domain name in the anchor text, then the hyphen is going to help you on the anchor text.

It probably helps some, but I would not concern myself if I could not get the ideal domain name, as that minor advantage could easily be overcome iin other ways.

caveman

8:24 pm on Feb 3, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member caveman is a WebmasterWorld Top Contributor of All Time 10+ Year Member



It makes a big difference with Google, and an enormous difference with Yahoo and MSN

Heh, heh, steveb, I thought you were one of those that railed against "kw-kw2-kw3-kw4.net".

Anyway, to say that it makes a 'big difference' in G is simply not true. No, wait. I can't say that because as BigDave points out, none of us reallly knows. What I think I can say that it's a 'big exageration.'

If it does make any difference at all in G, the difference is so minimal that across the many sites we manage, some of which contain hyphens-kw's and some of which do not, there is no visible correlation between the two sets. (Meaning, the many other SEO and site marketing factors involved are of such greater importance that it's not worth naming sites with hyphens anymore.)

Certainly it has always made a difference in Y!, but this is a G forum, and the question posed was specific to G. With Y!, while I'd agree kw-in-domain matters to an extent, the days of spamming Y! with "kw-kw2-kw3-kw4.net" domain to get high rankings stopped about two years ago.

Don't get me wrong, we have those kw-in-domain.com's. We just don't place much value on them as SEO tools anymore, since SEO is only part of site marketing, and in the context of site marketing, having more professional looking names, and preferably brandable domains, makes more sense.

Gee, I wonder if it would help WebmasterWorld.com to rename itself with a hyphen in between the two words. Nah. Too many good inbounds to the current version at this point. Plus there are all those redirect issues. ;-)

[edited by: caveman at 8:43 pm (utc) on Feb. 3, 2005]

robster124

8:38 pm on Feb 3, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Whether it makes a difference or not, what is undoubtedly the case is that an all in one word domain is often easier to advertise, easier to sloganise and neater.

If you want to get to the top of the SERPS for your KW, expend your efforts getting good anchor text KW links to your site.

 

Featured Threads

Hot Threads This Week

Hot Threads This Month