Forum Moderators: phranque
1. Do you have as many inbound links as they do? Are your as high quality as theirs?
2. Do they have any special site features (databases, sections, tools, forums etc.. ) that your site does not have? Could think be bringing is the people?
3. What is your SERP compared to theirs? Could there be very popular keywords that they are optimized for that you havent thought of?
4. Are they doing special advertising? (PPC? etc..)
5. Are they using offline methods to get traffic?
6. Does there site have a strong community?
yes, the "email this" feature does work to draw visitors but it will be maybe 1 in 500 visitors who use it. don't expect a huge boost in traffic but it is traffic that is much more likely to be very interested in what you have to sell, if you sell stuff.
You need to step back and view your site like a guy that just bought the site.
Let's say for this post that you are selling cars. The other site is selling comparable cars for about the same price. They are drawing 15-30 times the traffic you are and by implication selling 15-30 times as many cars..
First your problem is not their traffic. You are not failing to sell your cars because they are selling theirs. They are not part of your problem. You might be able to gain an insight on why you are under performing but in the end you have to solve your own problems.
Next they are being 15-30 times as effective at doing it as your site. That means that there is a whole lot of room for improvement.
Consider what the money value would be if you doubled your traffic. Make that amount your budget and spend it wisely.
Get outside help if need it to determine what steps are needed to double your traffic.
Remember that traffic is only part of the equation. Let’s say you convert 2% of the traffic to sales. If you double your traffic (in theory) you double your sales. But if you double your conversion rate to 4% and keep the same traffic you accomplish the same thing.