Forum Moderators: phranque

Message Too Old, No Replies

Sitewide Nav Bar - along top of page or down left side?

does it make any difference where it's placed re SEO

         

elaineb

9:38 am on Nov 19, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



Does it make any difference to any of the major SE where a sitewide nav bar is placed?

I've always placed my (rather bulky & extensive) nav bar across the top of my pages, so it was the first thing the spiderbots indexed.

Twice I've changed it and moved it down the left hand column and used the top of the page simply for my logo, sitemap link and 640 x 120 banner ad - makes for a much prettier page and more content is visible above the 'fold' - an added bonus was the page view increased slightly.

BUT on both occasions a few weeks after moving it I've been hit with the Google Drop. Panicked the first time and changed the nav bar back to the top of the page immediately - took 9 weeks to get back to my 'usual' position.

Moved it back down the left column in September and 7th October - week before Jagger update - dropped approx 40 places, and still down there - I've, again, put the old navbar back across the top of the pages and it's obviously not made any difference.

QUESTION - Have I just been unlucky with my timing - would I have dropped anyway - or do the SE spiderbots prefer the very top of the page to the left hand column for a sitewide navbar.

views very much appreciated.

LostOne

6:58 pm on Nov 19, 2005 (gmt 0)

10+ Year Member



"Does it make any difference to any of the major SE where a sitewide nav bar is placed?

I never considered it, along with the millions of other theories I've seen in the Google forum. Well, in my earlier days under a different screen name I did chase a few wild ones following the stampede effect that never works! Patience and a well structured site pays off but you'll always see fluctuations.

Webwork

8:31 pm on Nov 19, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Administrator 10+ Year Member Top Contributors Of The Month



Principal "thin" utility nav up top: home, site map, about, contact, etc. + logo as a link and possibly a site search box up top.

Auxiliary nav at bottom: copyright, tos, etc.

Site subject nav on the left, or in some circumstances, on the right.

Above pretty much describes the norm.

Kirby

1:14 am on Nov 20, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



Use css and absolute positioning and you can place it anywhere you want without having it be the first thing the spider finds.

kaled

2:20 pm on Nov 20, 2005 (gmt 0)

WebmasterWorld Senior Member 10+ Year Member



If navigational links contain keywords then position on the page may be a factor. As Kirby say, using CSS to position the navbar should be ok, BUT, I would suggest using an external style sheet. So far as I am aware, Google still ignores these so provided the html code for the navbar is near the <body> tag, its visual position is likely to have no effect on SERPS.

Kaled.