As you can see number of question arises for 301, 302 redirect of dynamic URL and there are handful of experienced resources who can actually know the answer with logic and its very difficult for them to keep on answering all the time for such questions. So, I wanna request you to pls start a topic which will stick to top with answer of such common redirects with reason.
There is no guarantee that all newcomers will read that topic and get there query resolved before asking, but definitely not all but some will read and not keep of putting common question again and again....
and coming to your second query i.e. disregarding Example.com or comply with forum, its better to straightforward ignore such topic or highlighted that this topic is not complied.
As far as mine submission is concerned, i've written Example.com which is as per direction
It's better to not to comment on one particularly who you don't know,
I'm not a technical person or webmaster, I'm director of public limited company and hundred of guys like you are reporting to me (which is actually out of syllabus for you, as these things are not tough anywhere) .... i come here in free time just to see how to make my dozens of site more and more better...
As a member of a forum that is addicted to Stickies, some of them dating from 2006, in such numbers that you have to scroll past them just to get to the real posts-- and then scroll back because some of those Sticky threads are active and ongoing--
Noooo! Pleease! The more stickies there are, the more likely people are to ignore them.
Besides, there are lots of forums where you can post a question and someone will jump right in and answer, even if they have already answered the identical question eight times in the past three days.
:: wandering off to compose boilerplate on Why We Don't Do It That Way with accompanying analogy about cleaning child's room ::