Out of curiosity: I was wondering if a few of us can share their organic traffic (rough estimate) vs Number of Pages. I'd be interested to see any correlation.
I'll start myself: (Search Engine Traffic)
Website #1, 2006:
7 pages (excluding the About Us, Contact Us ...pages), 300 visitors/day
Website #2, 2007:
6,000 pages, 800 visitors/day
Website #3, 2012:
12,000 Pages, 60 visitors/day (although recently its about <10 due to some sort of penalty)