weeks
msg:3570994 | 6:24 pm on Feb 10, 2008 (gmt 0) |
Very interesting, Pete. Thanks for the news. We're looking at security on a new project we're starting now. Our PHP people have outlined some annoying problems with the basic email link after registering with user name and password. Our new site will have the attention of teens and pre-teens, so they might take a run at playing around with it. Anyone here know of providers of this kind of "sign in seal" that Yahoo is providing? Anyone else had any experience with this, good or bad? I'd be interested in reading a paper or report on the pros and cons of this. As YahooPete's link noted, this kind of thing is getting common at banks now.
|
mikedee
msg:3571001 | 6:52 pm on Feb 10, 2008 (gmt 0) |
I do not think you will need a provider, it would be fairly simple for you to implement (assuming there are no patents on it or anything) The system works like this... 1. User uploads a photo or special text.
2. Yahoo dumps a cookie on this computer with a reference to the image.
3. When the user visits yahoo they will see their photo or message, if it is not there then they know it is a scam. It sounds like a good idea.
|
chrisv1963
msg:3571018 | 7:22 pm on Feb 10, 2008 (gmt 0) |
"This is available in the US market only" Will Yahoo ever learn that the Internet is a global thing?
|
Lord Majestic
msg:3571019 | 7:23 pm on Feb 10, 2008 (gmt 0) |
The problem with those scams is that victims are usually the people who will never even consider uploading such images, and those who do are probably careful enough not to fall for scams that typically come from email spams.
|
swa66
msg:3571193 | 2:03 am on Feb 11, 2008 (gmt 0) |
Social engineering for the bad guys around such a measure is trivial. All they have to say is that there is a (unspecified) problem with the system and the victim needs to do something.
[What they are already telling victims anyway to get their passwords.] Limiting to one country in the world seems well ... not what the Internet is about.
|
weeks
msg:3571198 | 2:09 am on Feb 11, 2008 (gmt 0) |
I do not believe you upload a picture. Instead, you select a picture from a list. Why did Yahoo put this on the search accounts, but not, say, email?
|
jcoronella
msg:3571207 | 3:19 am on Feb 11, 2008 (gmt 0) |
>> Why did Yahoo put this on the search accounts, but not, say, email? It is available for mail - that is where I saw it first (over a year ago?)
|
rushglen
msg:3571260 | 6:02 am on Feb 11, 2008 (gmt 0) |
I live in Canada and I have just created a Sign-in seal for my email account - which is uk based.......? trouble is the form doesn't work with Mozilla firefox but does with IE7 and I never use IE. Yahoo should make it clearer to people who may not know that this is a browser based strategy not one that is based on "your computer". interesting idea, but is still vunerable to cookie hijacking.
|
webjourneyman
msg:3571745 | 8:09 pm on Feb 11, 2008 (gmt 0) |
"This is available in the US market only." I beg to differ, I'm in Iceland and have already set it up. Might explain though why the first one I entered ca. one month ago disappeared again. I was worried for a while that the phishers ruled my computer.
|
|
