Sgt_Kickaxe - 12:40 pm on Dec 12, 2012 (gmt 0)
Exactly g1smd, and I do have some really good incoming links to some pages with index.php/ Lucy that I haven't been able to get the site owners to change although Googlebot is my primary concern.
I really don't want to slow down the site but some urls with index.php/ in them even bring in traffic so... hmmm. I think I'll go over the logs and figure out just how many index.php/ redirects are a must. Redirecting a few important ones in htaccess and letting all the rest, 404's included, get a proper 404 response might be the way to go.