You guys are very helpful. :) I just realized I do have php extensions on my formmail.php and formmailerror.php. There's no strange htaccess vudo that I'm not thinking of that could throw a problem with those is there if I'm only using HTML in the rule sets on my main domain?
Lol my repeated questions probably stems from the fact that I am not comfortable playing with code I don't understand. Specially code like this that can break my site. With CSS I'm like you guys. I look at big string of code and can follow it in my head 20 steps out. Frustrating. I'm used to being on the other end of the questions.