Yup, ATW 'SHOULD' have found my site by now.
I have already emailed ATW a bunch of times over the last 1-2 years asking why my site have never been listed and guessing that it must be banned due to some type of glitch. I don't remember the first emails so well since it was so long ago, but I never got a reply from an actual human. I might have gotten a useless "here are the basics of getting a site listed" reply. My most recent email that I sent a few weeks ago didn't even get one of those.
I guess I could just keep on emailing them every few weeks, but it doesn't seem like it will do any good. Is there an AllTheWeb guy around here, like a Googleguy? I'd really love to solve this. After all, it's only been 2 years.