Update: The content did get pushed to front page of Google today. We are at #6 or #7 in the results for the very specific keywords.
What's more surprising is that the web pages that are outranking us were created just yesterday and have '2013' in their title! Content wise, they are not even 5% of what we are offering. In fact ~30% of their content is copied!
It's very shocking how Google ranks pages.