JS_Harris - 6:41 am on Jul 25, 2013 (gmt 0)
Just to be a stickler for the little details, oldfriend, is the keyword phrase you are referring to your site's primary keyword phrase?
I still see them at No. 5 spot for the keyword phrase and my site is not in the SERPs at ALL
To see how your individual article is ranking against the copied url you need to do a copy paste of various parts of the article such as the exact title if the scraper copied that too or for a snippet of the text wrapped in quotation marks. You can't do a keyword search and see where your index page ranks against theirs when the problem is as you describe, you need to compare page by page and I didn't get the impression that's what you did. Forgive me if I am wrong.