Since when did being an ethical person become characteristic of being a hippie? Is being ethical and upright worthy of scorn and derision?
Or does this suit you better?
I'm as cold a #*$! as you've ever put your #*$! eyes on. I don't give a #*$! about those people.
You built a lousy site. Made money off it. Then Google penalized the site and now you're trying to make money off a dead site by charging people to remove links from it. Walk away, the body is cold. No need to keep flogging it. Create something better. Charging people to remove a link is parasitic, indecent, and dishonorable.
A normal person with a sense of decency would allow the domain to expire.