SEOPanda - 12:31 am on Apr 27, 2013 (gmt 0)
taberstruths - why would you noindex it and then canonical it, you're giving google the hint that the value should be going to your good URL... doesn't seem to make sense.
tedster - after our spam attack, the page I want to 404 stopped ranking completely... I think 404'ing it would be the best bet, as it's likely only spreading negative seo value around the site.
what are your thoughts on that?