Jez123 - 5:07 pm on Feb 4, 2013 (gmt 0)
I would ask one more question (although I'm pretty confident I know the answer)
Is there any reason to disavow anything if you only got devalued by PENGUIN?
I say NO! ...PENGUIN already disavowed them for you.
Google is such a waste of time. I think they just laugh at us! Why can't they just say what they mean and what they want? Webmasters are panicking, removing all and sundry links, most of which probably are not an issue. And what's the point? How many sites have returned after using it? I don't know of any. Maybe a couple of high profile ones have returned but I have not heard of any Penguin recoveries where the site was hit and no WMT "inorganic links" notice was served.
I know for a fact that I have removed too many links and there is no way that my site will rank even if Penguin gets lifted. We would all have been better scrapping our sites and starting again - but no, google gives us hope by dangling carrots. This is our livelihoods and mortgages they are messing about with.