Planet13 - 9:49 pm on Jan 9, 2013 (gmt 0)
"I'd also agree, stay consistent."
Unfortunately for me, that isn't an option.
I use hyphens through the site.
However, this one page (which currently has a hyphen between words) became Penguin fodder. Haven't been able to get it back onto page one no matter what I have tried.
So was thinking of changing the hyphen to an underscore FOR THIS ONE PAGE and then NOT doing a 301 redirect.
Still thinking about it...