crobb305 - 9:01 pm on Oct 15, 2012 (gmt 0)
I feel like the algorithm could be viewing these pages as spam, just because some of the commentary are so redundant.
I may noindex, nofollow the older pages of UGC. Bad idea? I am scared to make any moves these days. The site is Penguinized, and I personally feel like Penguin is about spam on AND off page (not just inbound links). So I am doing what I can to reduce anything that could be perceived as spam.