claaarky - 8:57 am on Sep 26, 2012 (gmt 0)
I thought MC made that suggestion about starting afresh in connection to Penguin, not Panda.
I don't believe Panda 'burns' domains because it's all about the quality of the content, which can be changed.
My guess is Google asked for feedback on Panda as a way to verify it was doing its' job accurately, in the same way we ask for feedback on our sites even though we may feel they are already perfect. Panda was a major change to things so Google would be crazy not to ask for feedback. They've always said they're very happy with it though, and haven't updated it for months.