rango - 12:57 pm on Aug 23, 2012 (gmt 0)

No reply / no answer question pages being indexed are not going to pass the quality sniff test. (If I were a user and landed on one, I would be pretty steamed)

Interesting. We allow these to be indexed also, but only for threads that are less than a year old. My main concern was that if I noindex them to start off with and then that changes, Google might have a hard time picking it up. Or at least we might miss the freshness boost for those.

But then, recently it seems sitemaps are pretty good at forcing another look-in.