MarvinH - 12:31 pm on Jul 14, 2012 (gmt 0)
2 sentences on (for example, a great question followed by the perfect answer)
Claaarky, I cannot agree more. I have one such page on my forum. The page consists of a very short question consisting of fewer than 30 words, and an even shorter 8 word answer with a single link to a downloadable .zip file. Certainly one of the shortest threads on my forum. It's a typical page many people in SEO communities would consider "thin content" deserving noindexing, excluding in robots.txt, or even deleting. Yet, this page, for the past well over a year, has been receiving a lot of clicks from Google search results, a lot more than product reviews consisting of thousands of words, numerous images, and hundreds of replies (no ads, no aff links, just pure reviews, it's a non-commercial site, a hobby site).