scooterdude - 9:45 am on Jul 12, 2012 (gmt 0)
That suggestion makes sense to me. If I'm looking at the NY page, the content should be about the NY location rather than generic boilerplate that I can find on the Chicago page and the St Louis page and... I would expect the more generic content to be on a top level page.
Surely this presumes that the users behave like googlebot and scan every city page even though they just want a Pizza in NY?
How do you get annoyed about boiler plate if you never see it?