Leosghost - 10:27 am on Jun 29, 2012 (gmt 0)
Therefore we can't simply say "It's not a good business model, plain and simple."
We can..( based upon your original post ) ..you may not wish to..
But, I'm curious , how are you analysing a site without knowing its name,
I don't know I've not seen his site
did he not want to tell you the name ..you are clairvoyant ? or do you just avert your eyes from where the domain name is ,when looking at his stats and his serp position..or does he "redact" all of that out before he asks you questions or shows you figures, ..never clicked to see ?
This sounds like you do the SEO equivalent of inter continental psychic healing..but without even the photo of the "patient"..