I don't object to dissenting opinion. What I object to is people who say the theory is wrong because of something that is not part of my theory
claaarky, your theory suffers from the same flaws as any other Panda theory that has been brought so far does. They are all unfounded. All are pure speculation.
It just seems that induction logic is not the proper tool to understand Panda. Generalization of a single website analysis won't lead us anywhere. Any conclusion you will draw from your analytics - an innumerable number of counter-examples will be found. There too many factors in play.