aristotle - 7:38 pm on Jun 5, 2012 (gmt 0)

No, no and no. If the page were over-optimized* then it would simply not fit what the algorithm wants to see. If the algorithm wants to see this...

Sorry, this isn't what over-optimization means. And in fact over-optimization penalities do exist. At one Matt Cutts referred to Penquin as an over-optimization penalty.