Wilburforce - 3:44 pm on Jun 16, 2012 (gmt 0)
I'm finding myself on page 1, visitors are not, according to my analytics package
Google is now doing something "smart" with cookies, and I have had the same (local to this computer) effect a few times lately. I think it is more likely to happen if you are logged in to WMT, but can happen if you are not. If e.g. you try your term for your page, then find your page on page 6 of the results and open it from there, the next time you search it is at the top of page 1. You then need to clear your cache and delete all Google cookies to get back to "normal" results.