This last page is so confusing!
SEChecker - you've been lumping TMS in with bluntforce, whose post is still there, unedited on Page 9. TMS is NOT dismissing the theory or suggesting anyone's looking for excuses or just whining or any of that. He is asking probing questions that helped backdraft7 and Shaddows construct responses which made it even MORE clear that whatever this is, it's Google related.
TMS is trying to help. Please go back and re-read bluntforce's comment and then re-read TMS's separately. He's offering some exceedingly valuable data - patterns observed in not just several websites, but several on- and offline businesses. This is exactly the sort of data we need, and I feel you've misjudged his intentions here completely.