johnhh - 10:01 pm on Dec 15, 2011 (gmt 0)
We are doing the same , come the next Panda update we will see what happens.
I would noindex it; remove it from sitemap.xml; and even block its indexing in robots.txt
Objective: is the page useful for our visitors = yes - as reported in web statistics. Is it thin or details found elsewhere i.e. waste of time being in Google index =yes. If yes to both remove from Google but keep page.
If we have thin pages not found elsewhere we keep them in.
We will see...