superclown2 - 9:26 am on Oct 1, 2011 (gmt 0)
I just received a message back from my reconsideration request. The answer is the usual template "Some pages still violate our guidelines."
That's great to know, but which pages are they? I'll probably never know. There is no way I'm going through thousands of pages with their long guidelines.
The only thing left for me is the hope that the penalty was set because of the domain change, which brought over 10K links from the old domain (even though I set 301 redirects. Amazing algorithm...)
Try getting your logs out and looking at the ones they looked at, and it might well give you a clue. They don't normally look at very many.