CainIV - 2:54 am on Sep 12, 2011 (gmt 0)
My sites don't disappear, never mind permanently. Never. Not in almost 10 years - not since I started. They don't even get algo bans.
That's fantastic, and hat's off to you, but this doesn't mean that permanent lifetime bans are either appropriate or fair.
Just like in the real court system, if Google wants to be fair there will be fair appeal (which there is not)