cien took a look at the site and found it a joke. The article posted was about "hey we got this domain name and it don't show up the search inside google so google is hiding our site on purpose." Black box theory.
I looked at the same search well dude your now #1 and then looked at the age of the domian. They bought the domain on 3-10 so it was at the time of Caffeine. Now if the dude that wrote the article had a clue then he would have know why, but since he doesn't then the site to me is a joke and just a way I see they are trying to get info to funnel more than likely to some attorney.
I have no need for a site such as this.
To get back on topic though I can't see were Google is broke. I can find a search here and there that is kinda outta wack but for the most part their search results are on target. I can do the same thing for Bing and Yahoo. To base a search engine is broke on one search is IMO a joke as well and should not be the basis for posting the results are broke.
Take a list of say 30 terms do a search on each engine and then compare I bet your results will be different.