Robert_Charlton - 4:09 pm on May 21, 2009 (gmt 0)

We set to detect IF https protocal was requested.. - If so, we set onpage meta robots to block access for https requests. There have never been any meta robots on any http page.

If you've somehow managed to set up two sets of dedicated files, one for https requests and another set of dedicated files for http requests, this would make sense.

But, when one of your "http pages" has received an https request, adding the noindex robots meta tag to that page is going to block further http access to that page as well, since there would be only one file serving both protocols.

Again, you are indicating that your "old http pages" haven't gotten listed again... and, from my understanding of your description, I believe this is the reason why.