Shaddows - 1:34 pm on Feb 2, 2009 (gmt 0)

To be honest, its easy to spot something thats going wrong from short desriptions, because people already have an idea that something isn't right. They're just looking for validation befor they do what they know they should anyway.

Confirmational answers often end up in discussions of grey areas (such as "should I shrink my menu from 100 links" will get two or more lines of thought).

Yours is a case study. Hard to unpick. And frankly some members here would be expecting a hefty fee to answer you. You might avaoid the fee and get a better analysis by paying for membership and posting in the site review [webmasterworld.com] forum.