Lord_Majestic - 6:30 pm on Aug 21, 2008 (gmt 0)

if their sites rank top 3 for allintitle/allinanchor/etc. then why aren't they ranking in the real SERPs?

Probably because real SERPs take into account more params than just title/anchor.

link: stats shown by Google are totally far away from reality - it is simply not worth using it, which is probably Google wanted to achieve with their tweaks.