drall - 12:12 pm on Oct 12, 2007 (gmt 0)

We had this happen to a site about 2 years ago, same stats as you in webmaster tools etc but still smoked in Google. I asked someone I know at Google about it and they could not figure it out and she is a real life friend who would not lie. The site is very popular via word of mouth so I could care less and have left the site be to see if Google ever corrects itself, which by the way it hasnt.