That isn't even remotely what I was saying. Intelligent conversation is impossible if you don't read carefully.
My point was (and still is) that there is great utility in providing similar, nearly duplicate, entries in the search results.
You are contending that Google is too stupid to do this properly. You may be right but I don't think that's your point. Search engines are still quite primitive and the more I examine them the more I realize that the promise is very far from reality.
Comparison shopping cuts across all lines, you can "shop" for informational sites, indeed "shop" for anything. Comparison is what search is all about. A complaint about repetitive listings in the serps is just a complaint that search engines aren't smart enough to read your mind. This sarcasm about baking bread is an insult and betrays a lack of understanding of this...