Sparkys_Dad - 10:21 pm on Nov 21, 2005 (gmt 0)

That's not my experience. There are many sites with top tens on one engine and nowhere on the others.

I would say your experience is not the norm. The Google, Yahoo and MSN algos obviously differ, but not so much that you can be top ten on one engine and "nowhere" on another--unless you have been penalized.

While you've made it clear that it is your personal experience which causes you to disagree, your "proof" is a bit vague as it fails to indicate whether or not the "many" sites that exhibit this phenomena are a also part of your personal experience.