Come on Adam. Are we supposed to take this seriously?
I recently commented on (and reported) a site that was using a particularly efficient cloak/redirect.. the landing page was nothing more than 3 sentences of keyword loaded useless info, but wait...there was adsense at top.
These particular subdomains were dominating thousands of two and three-word "money" keywords (not only "blue widgets in anytownville", but terms like "buy blue widgets" "cheap blue widgets", etc).
Went bye bye, and now is back - ranking...but instead of it redirecting to MFA (guess you closed their account), it redirects to a dating site, for ALL the keyword terms.
Are you telling us this site ranks "in spite" of being useless?!