janharders - 3:24 pm on May 21, 2009 (gmt 0)

that's up to your definition of cloaking.
Cloaking to me is serving different content at the same resource to users and bots, without a redirect.
redirecting users with javascript is far easier to see for bots and outdated. that said, it still works (or worked, I've seen a page recently that ranked well and used that style ... can't remember which query I used, though).