IanCP - 5:16 am on Nov 17, 2009 (gmt 0)

Hmm an interesting problem. For over a decade I have had similar sites yet I've not experienced any montising problem. Only magnitude.

I can't give you possible answers because under the circumstances we're all largely asking each other "how long is a piece of string".

I can say I am mightily surprised by your post though.

I certainly haven't seen among the suggested answers anything remotely feasible. Sorry folks, that's just the way it is.

Don't dilute your content with crap. In fact don't fool around with anything until you are absolutely certain what you are doing and why. I really mean that, I've burnt my fingers in the past.

Forget the "value added subscription" idea. I can't ever see it working except in very exceptional circumstances.

Selling product is one option but can create a lot of other unwanted headaches.

Taken entirely at face value, I must confess I didn't think I'd ever see such a post as yours. You would appear to have done everything right. In fact you seem to be everything I've ever advocated newcomers to do.

Mate, I'm truly perplexed and bewildered.

You didn't mention how many pages you have, traffic, a rough idea of AdSense CTR etc. It could be a bit of a guide for us. We're largely whistling in the dark.