wheel - 12:19 pm on Feb 24, 2011 (gmt 0)
It's a learning curve for the forum. I personally would've voted yes to allowing this type of thread (not that anyone asked me)....until after this thread. As tedster noted, this thread lead to Overstock getting slapped by Google, but not slapped for their methods. Instead, they were slapped for public relations reasons. Google decided to make s*** up for this one.
So while some of us might have a case where reviewing specific methods in the daylight is good, and let the chips fall where they may, when companies get penalized for PR instead of bad tactics by Google, then I agree, not something to be a part of. Keep it to pubcon and leave the hysteria for the traditional press.