rfgdxm1 - 5:53 am on Apr 5, 2003 (gmt 0)

>There isn't anything in the guidelines that says an editor shouldn't exclude all sites with blue text. Based on your logic should sites with blue text be excluded?

But was it anything that arbitrary? Was this unquestionably a site with original, unique and valuable informational content? Consider that valuable is a subjective determination.

>Exactly. So why are all of these editors who haven't even looked at the site coming to the defense of the one editor who did? Does being an ODP editor bestow some sort of infalliblity onto a person that other editors will simply back him up without any question?

No. However, you haven't put forth any evidence the decision was totally unreasonable. If you believe so, than Resource Zone is the the most appropriate forum to debate such.